For this week's Brainstorm we have some books that look at the truth behind cryptid tales, their origins, and what real creatures or fake news may be behind the fantastic stories. To see my full summaries/reviews of each title plus any content notes/trigger warnings, please scroll below.
My Full Summaries/Reviews:
Catching Cryptids: The Scientific Search for Mysterious Creatures by Kim Long, ill. by Nicole Miles
This is one part survey of different cryptids from around the world and one part introduction to various tech and scientific methods useful in field research. Long introduces a variety of different cryptids, looks at what kind of animal it could be or could be mistaken for such a creature, whether anything similar has been found, what kind of scientific equipment and methods could be used to find evidence of the creature, and other similar cryptids around the globe.
This was a fascinating read. You learn how scientists find real rare animals, like using radar or environmental DNA or camera traps or a whole host of other things. I had heard about some of these methods, but some were brand new to me (like the environmental DNA…that was fascinating). The book realistically shows how you would go about developing a plan to find a rare creature. It highlights some past cryptids that have been discovered to be inspired by real creatures, like the giant squid inspiring kraken tales. There were a whole host of cryptids in here I had never heard of before. And I felt like it dealt with things very scientifically. For example, they say something like…‘We’ve got numerous reports of people saying they saw a creature with these attributes.” And then they research if any known animals match the description, and then scientifically describe how to narrow down the search field and what equipment would be most useful. The science nerd in me loved this. It was done in a very readable and engaging way, and is a fantastic read for any would-be scientists.
Notes on content: Language: None, Sexual content: None, Violence: Animals that are predators or have been said to attack others are mentioned, nothing graphic., Ethnic diversity: Cryptid examples come from all over the globe, LGBTQ+ content: None specified, Other: Beware of high science content (but done in a fun and engaging way)!
Loch Ness Uncovered: Media, Misinformation, and the Greatest Monster Hoax of All Time by Rebecca Siegel
Rebecca Siegel relates how prior to the 1900s, there were no rumors of a monster in Loch Ness. It wasn't until one woman claimed she saw something in 1933 that rumors started to fly. Siegel relates how the rumors built, how photos were stage, the role King Kong played in the building of the myth, how it helped a struggling economy, and the lengths people have gone to prove or disprove Nessie's existence. In conclusion, Siegel's gives readers pointers in recognizing fake news and not spreading modern day rumors.
This was a fascinating read. I had no idea there was no literature or record of tales of the Loch Ness monster until 1933. This was a fantastic bit of research, investigative reporting, engaging nonfiction writing, and making connections to modern day fake news and how to be savvy readers. Highly recommended.
Notes on content: Language: There might have been 1 minor swear in a quote, Sexual content: None, Violence: Deaths of people from old age or in wars is mentioned, Ethnic diversity: Scottish, South African, and more, LGBTQ+ content: I don't remember anyone mentioned, Other: Part of the story involves a staged hunt for the monster, staged footprints, and a staged photograph (the one on the cover). Debates as to motives people had for sharing tales of sightings.
What Do We Know about the Kraken? (What Do We Know About...?) by Ben Hubbard, ill. by Robert Squier
An examination of the earliest appearances of stories about sea monsters, most specifically the kraken. The book then explores what real creature might have sparked these stories, such as perhaps the giant squid and how our knowledge of the giant and colossal squids have grown in the past couple hundred years.
This was the best What Do We Know about... book I've read so far. I like how it examined the relationship between sea monster stories/myths and our lack of knowledge about what lives in the worlds' oceans, and how discoveries about giant squids and colossal squids seem to explain where many of the kraken stories may have come from. Hand this to curious readers, random fact sponges, and sea monster fans.
Notes on content: Language: None, Sexual content: None, Violence: Fictional stories of sea monster attacks wrecking ships and drowning sailors are mentioned. Whale/squid battles are recounted and the injuries they can leave on each other, Ethnic diversity: Kraken-like tales from around the globe are related. Scientists from Europe, Japan, and New Zealand are highlighted, LGBTQ+ content: None, Other: Inspections of dead squid are described and some illustrations are included.















