Today’s Brainstorm focuses on books that address the question, What happens to characters who had amazing adventures in portal worlds and then come back to everyday life? How are they changed by their experiences, and how do they adjust to going from major hero to just an average kid/teen? C.S. Lewis briefly touched on this in some of his Narnia books, but I’m highlighting 3 books in which this is a main topic of the book. Which begs a further question, why do authors highlight this kind of experience? How can readers take these book experiences and apply the lessons to real life? As an expat I have a lot of ideas, but I don’t think it is limited to cross-cultural experiences, and I’ll leave you to ponder other applications as you go through your day. Click on the titles to see my full reviews of each book plus any content notes/trigger warnings.
Cheshire Crossing by Andy Weir, ill. by Sarah Andersen
In a nutshell: Alice (of Wonderland wanderings), Dorothy (of Oz whirlwind tours), and Wendy (of Neverland flights of fancy) are all sent to a boarding school for girls with their peculiar backgrounds.
More info: What do you do with a little girl who says she's been to this strange and magical land during the days she was missing from home? Get her psychological help. And if they persist in those stories? Then you jump at the opportunity when a man with a boarding school specifically for young people with these issues comes knocking. That's how Alice Liddell, Dorothy Gale, and Wendy Darling all find themselves at a boarding school run by Mr. Ernest Rutherford with the help of a Ms Poole. Dorothy and Wendy are ok with being at the school, but Alice is determined to escape at the first opportunity. And Dorothy's magical shoes just might be the ticket. Oz can't be worse than Wonderland, right? Wendy tries to stop Alice, and soon both of them find themselves targets of a certain Wicked Witch. Meanwhile, Dorothy is trying to rescue them with the help of Ms Poole. In adventure that bridges from Oz to Wonderland to Neverneverland, the girls must outwit the new plans of the Wicked Witch, save each other, and get back to a safe place.
Extra thoughts: I enjoyed the concept of Alice, Dorothy, and Wendy meeting quite a lot. It was also rather creative of Weir to ask what their lives would have been like after they returned and then to have their worlds blend together. Understandably, the girls have responded to their life-altering adventures differently.
Target readers: Graphic Novel Fans, Fantasy Fans, Adventure Fans, Fanfic of Classics Fans, Young Adult Readers
Once a Queen (Carrick Hall, #1) by Sarah Arthur
In a nutshell: During a summer visit to her grandmother’s estate in England, Eva uncovers long-buried secrets about fantastical journeys and how it impacted her grandmother and others.
More info: Eva and her mother are visiting Carrick Hall, home of her maternal grandmother, for the first time in Eva's life. Eva is enchanted by the grand mansion, the stories of fantastical worlds, and the midnight romps she goes on with her grandmother (during which her grandmother thinks Eva is her long, lost sister). Some people tell Eva the place is magical and children have gone to other worlds from the Hall, and Eva thinks the former owner wrote about the adventures of these girls from her grandmother's generation in her fantasy books. Her grandmother firmly denies it, however, her mother hates being there for some reason, the household staff are sworn to not tell Eva anything her mother or grandmother don't tell her, and Eva is very frustrated with all the secrets she's both asked to keep and that are being held from her. What happened during her grandmother's youth that left secrets galore and a pall over Carrick Hall?
Extra thoughts: An atmospheric read that has a magical realism feel and keeps you guessing until the very end as to all the secrets being kept. This story tackles the generational impact of portal adventures, and the story sees slow healing for old wounds in multiple characters, and promises hope for the future.
Target readers: Magical Realism Fans, English Manor Setting Fans, Multi-generational Family Story Fans, Slow Burn Family Mystery Fans, Young Adult Readers (complex enough for Adult Readers and approachable for high reading Middle Grade Readers)
The Quest for The Guardians (The DreamKeeper Saga, #4) by Kathryn Butler
In a nutshell: A seasoned adventurer and heroine in the Realm must contend with returning to Earth, being a normal girl, protecting people from a new danger invading Earth but also honoring her father who has a bit of PTSD from his own experiences in the Realm.
More info: Lily has returned from the Realm excited to see her family but also missing the Realm a bit. She has dreams of her whole family visiting the Realm in the future, but those dreams come crashing down when she sees how her long absence and her father's experiences in the Realm have jaded him. He wants to have nothing to do with it and demands that Lily have nothing to do with it either. He even demands that she turn over her sooth stone to him, and he hides it away from her. Lily brought Mattie back and now they need to find her father, but her father is trying to travel back in time and stop Mattie from going into the Realm. While they are trying to find him, shrouds start showing up all over the world. Lily can't understand how they are getting here. What happened to the barrier? Can Pax even help in this world like in the Realm? One thing's for sure, Lily, Mattie, and her family can't stop the shroud invasion without help. They must travel the world to find other Guardians to help before the shrouds take over.
Extra thoughts: (Obviously, this is the 4th book in a series so if you feel a little lost reading the More Info, that's understandable. Here are my summaries of the first 3 boos to help: Book 1, Book 2, Book 3.) Lily’s father has some tough lessons to learn about trusting Pax with not only the Realm, but also his daughter and her safety. It is a hard lesson for him, which makes this sometimes a frustrating read but gets across a very important allegorical point.
Target readers: Fantasy Fans, Quest Story Fans, Christian Fiction Fans, Allegorical Story Fans, Adventure Fans, Middle Grade Readers